Plastic Bag Ban Won't Go Statewide Yet

By Kelly Hartog

A Senate Bill designed to ban the use of plastic bags in stores across the state of California failed to pass a Senate vote on vote Thursday. It did not receive the 21 votes needed to pass. The measure failed by a vote of 18-17 with four abstentions.

Had it passed, Senate Bill 405 - authored by Los Angeles Senator Alex Padilla - would have required grocery stores and other large retail organizations from providing shoppers with plastic bags starting on Jan. 1 2015.

Here is how the Senate voted:
Anderson, Joel - No
Beall, Jim - Yes
Berryhill, Tom - No
Block, Marty - Yes
Calderon, Ron - No
Cannella, Anthony - No
Corbett, Ellen M. - Yes
Correa, Lou - No
de León, Kevin - No
DeSaulnier, Mark - Yes
Emmerson, Bill - No
Evans, Noreen - Yes
Fuller, Jean - No
Gaines, Ted - No
Galgiani, Cathleen - Yes
Hancock, Loni - Yes
Hernandez, Ed - Yes
Hill, Jerry - Yes
Hueso, Ben
Huff, Bob - No
Jackson, Hannah-Beth - Yes
Knight, Steve - No
Lara, Ricardo - No
Leno, Mark -Yes
Lieu, Ted W. - Yes
Liu, Carol - Yes
Monning, Bill - Yes
Nielsen, Jim - No
Padilla, Alex - Yes
Pavley, Fran -Yes
Price, Jr., Curren D.
Roth, Richard D. - Yes
Steinberg, Darrell - Yes
Torres, Norma J. - No
Walters, Mimi - No
Wolk, Lois
Wright, Roderick D.
Wyland, Mark - No
Yee, Leland Y. - No

While the ban did not pass, the Senate did agree to Padilla's request to reconsider the bill, however there is no date set as to when that will happen. Manhattan Beach is one of 72 local governments in California that have a plastic bag ban; other cities include Malibu, Los Angeles County, San Francisco, Santa Monica, Long Beach, Pasadena and West Hollywood.

And at its May 14 meeting, the Culver City City Council unanimously agreed to introduce an ordinance banning single use carryout plastic bags. The ordinance will also require local retailers to charge customers 10 cents to use a paper bag.

Following the Senate vote, Culver City Mayor Jeff Cooper told Patch, "While saddened but not surprised at the defeat of SB 405, it pleases me that our council passed our plastic bag ban ordinance by a unanimous 5-0 vote."

However, Mark Daniels, chairman of the American Progressive Bag Alliance issued a statement supporting the Senate vote saying, “Today’s vote signals the facts have prevailed in this debate. A ban on 100 percent recyclable plastic bags would hurt the environment and threaten jobs. The American Progressive Bag Alliance works hard to protect American jobs in the plastic bag manufacturing and recycling industry – including 2,000 in California – and our organization has repeatedly called for an honest debate on this issue. We thank the members of the California Senate who rejected this misguided policy prescription based on unfounded stats, junk science and myths, and we hope lawmakers will continue to make responsible decisions on behalf of California’s environment and economy.”

What do you think? Should the ban go statewide? How has the ban worked for shoppers and retailers in Manhattan Beach? How has it worked for you?